Case of '12 Ginter or '11 BDPP...Help me decide!

[WNP22]

The time has come, the money is right...I will be purchasing my first case of baseball cards ever. Ooooo so excited!!!

Now, just looking for opinions. I've come down to either 2012 AG or 2011 BDPP. Both have their positive and both have their negatives.

--Ginter would be a more fun rip in my opinion, due to the amount of inserts and other crazy things in there, although I would have a blast with either one.

--BDPP probably has a more steady ROI, I believe, unless you guys enlighten me otherwise. (I've been around long enough to realize I'm not going to automatically make a profit on a case, but I'd at least like to make a little back.)

--BDPP is about $80 cheaper than AG with the Blowout weekend sale.

So, to go with a probably more fun, more volatile product in Ginter, or a slightly less fun, more stable ROI product in BDPP. What do you think? Look forward to hearing yall's opinions on the matter!

 

[devin]

ginter

 

[tramers]

ginter SELL inserts fast
Bowman longer to get return but one star pays off

 

[George_Calfas]

What do you normally collect? Which of these two products gives you a shot at a PC card? Do you just plan to bust/sell? If you go BDP do you have to grade to maximize your ROI?

 

[schmidtfan20]

gotta be ginter, the fun factor on ripping this stuff is off the charts. With all the chrome products you pull your one autograph and the rest is junk, with ginter
you always have the shot of nailing something nice.

Kevin

 

[CollectorsCorner]

IMO 2011 Draft is loaded with tons of guys that even their base auto will get you money back fast.

 

[ThoseBackPages]

really hard to compare the two.

 

[longbomberz]

I haven't opened Ginter beyond a couple blasters, but Draft has some really nice extra value with Bundy base selling well and green base of chrome of Trout, Rizzo and a couple others selling well.

 

[jofinn36]

Trout Base Cards in Bowman Draft are selling for decent amounts so Its not just the Autos or prospects.

 

[craftysouthpaw]

If you decide on Draft, I can sell you a sealed case at $50 under BO with free shipping.

 

[ThoseBackPages]

If you decide on Draft, I can sell you a sealed case at $50 under BO with free shipping.

XXXX, that's a great XXXXing gesture! Rock on brother!

 

[schmidtfan20]

plenty of trout in ginter also

 

[WNP22]

Thanks for the great offer. I'm going to decide in the next day or so, so if I decide on Draft I'll shoot you a PM.