How Did I Do On This Deal?

[arod305]

Still not sure how I did on this deal, would like others opinions. Scans below of cards

I got
2012 topps chrome trent richardson logo patch auto /50 BGS 9.5- POP 1/1
$125 gifted paypal

I sent
2012 Topps Chrome Trent Richardson Rookie Die Cut Super 1/1

I took the deal, because most I have had offered to me on the Diecut was $250, also only thing I really keep these days is high end rookie auto patches

 

[mstng99tim]

I'd rather have the superfractor.

 

[jeff_bichel]

You would have to pry a Superfractor out of my cold dead hands. Sorry, but IMHO not a good trade

 

[200lbhockeyplayer]

I never put too much stock in the population reports of modern cards. That said, the Chrome auto/patch rookie is nice.

I probably would have reached for $200 in Paypal, but if your only offers were in the $250 range, you did fine. Probably didn't maximize it, but money and that patch seem to fit your collection better.

 

[Logan2500]

I think for that card and $125, it isn't too bad.

 

[dp33]

I'll be the contrarian and say that I like the trade and would have made it myself. The base card superfractor might have been a different story, but I would have definitely traded the die-cut superfractor for that deal.

 

[mikekarlovec]

I like the trade. I think you did well

 

[ffgameman]

Good deal in my opinion, although the graded portion would be of no concern at all to me.

 

[CollectorsCorner]

I would say the card + $125 was worth more than the 1/1 by itself

 

[notjomommasclint]

You traded well..

but I like the die cut super!!


Sent from my motorolla startac.

 

[arod305]

I would say the card + $125 was worth more than the 1/1 by itself

Based off the offers I received this is diff. the case.

 

[f2tornado]

I would have kept the super myself but the deal is fair for both. I can tell you those auto/patch cards from Chrome are rare to find in gem mint condition so if you like autos and slabs then you did well. You now have a very nice auto/patch card and $125 to find more cool stuff or pay the light bill.