i might of just wasted some money - HELP?

[cmixer]

i bought a small lot of signed cards on eBAY -
he said "in-person" autos, at signings ...
but never provided true COA's or proof.

Can you confirm any of these autos?
(or disprove them?)
I imagine they are all good, or they are all fake.

 

[cmixer]

sorry for large scans, i thought you'd want to see details ...

 

[cmixer]

and the reason i bought the lot ...

... there's more, but these are the "big three" - i'll scan more if it'll help ...

 

[CollectorsCorner]

The Rodgers and Tebow don't look bad.... I still would have no idea if they were legit or not. The Tom Brady looks funny to me but again I couldn't say for 100% certainty either way.

 

[mstng99tim]

They look fake to me, however, I have a few Sidney Crosby autos that I got signed IP that many would think are fake and might not even pass any authentication service.

 

[cmixer]

any other help?
i'll take the good , or the bad news - i just want an idea before shilling out for PSA/DNA

 

[UWHusky11]

Back when I was younger, I used to buy signed photos of celebs with crap COA's that I could make myself with a "guarantee" of authenticity. I learned my lesson over time. Tommy Boy said it best: "If you want me to take a dump in a box and mark it guaranteed I will; I have spare time". I would urge you to only purchase cards that have been authenticated by the company, or memorabilia with a PSA/DNA. If I had to guess on these, I would say you lost your money on them. They all have the same straight lines and similar curves as though they were signed by one person. Sorry for the bad news but I don't think these will make it by any proof process. Hope you didn't spend to much on them!

 

[cmixer]

i totally understand i get what i paid for -
and i know i took a risk -
i'm just trying to see if we have any other auto experts on here who have an opinion.
Thanks so far everyone ...

 

[Brad]

There is something I just don't like about everything after the R in Rodgers. I also find it interesting that the Brady and Tebow are essentially the same angle on the card (especially with the T).

 

[Card Magnet]

Regardless of having or not having a COA, they are only as authentic as you believe them to be.

 

[jbrown]

There was a seller on ebay selling tons of Rodgers, Tebow, Brady, and Manning autos. How many of these did he have listed? Completed? If I had to guess, I would say fake. The Brady isn't close. Judging by the ink I would say they were all signed with the same pen.

 

[JEBJJA]

That Tebow especially looks alot inconsistant...very bad...sorry man.

 

[the1mcjensen]

imo, all are fake