Internet Rage Bait (Warning) Lindor v Jeter

[General_Says_Tso]

 

[General_Says_Tso]

I take Jeter all day obviously....

 

[Super Mario]

Jeet

 

[nosterbor]

Jeter

 

[michaelstepper]

You put jeter on any other team while the Yankees and everything else remain the same. Jeter is Paul molitor

 

[gt2590]

Lindor.

And Jose Ramirez over A-Rod.

 

[banjar]

Jeter. I've heard good things about his gift baskets.

 

[WizardofOz1982]

I'd take Lindor in a heartbeat. Through age 31 (this is Lindor's age 31 season) he's a good chunk of value (56.2 fWAR and he'll break 60 career this season compared to 45.7 for Jeter) better then Jeter. Offensively they're basically the same (125 wRC+ for Jeter vs 121 for Lindor) but Lindor is worlds better defensively (164 defensive value for Lindor vs -16.4 for Jeter).

If not for Jose Ramirez then Lindor would likely be the most underrated player in baseball currently.

 

[Philip J. Fry]

Lindor.

And Jose Ramirez over A-Rod.

I'd take anyone over A-Rod. Pre-Yankees, I might say otherwise, but he was just a mess in the Bronx. Remember The Slap™?

 

[jmc855]

Nomar before the injury. Boom.

 

[joey12508]

You put jeter on any other team while the Yankees and everything else remain the same. Jeter is Paul molitor

 

[Super Mario]

I'd take anyone over A-Rod. Pre-Yankees, I might say otherwise, but he was just a mess in the Bronx. Remember The Slap™?

View attachment 363973

Wonder how he would be remembered if he went to Boston instead of the Yankees like was originally attempted?

Some people just aren’t cut out for New York. Randy Johnson had a rough time too.

 

[joey12508]

Wonder how he would be remembered if he went to Boston instead of the Yankees like was originally attempted?

Some people just aren’t cut out for New York. Randy Johnson had a rough time too.

a lot of players who came to the darkside couldnt cut it.

just the pitchers

Kei Igawa,Hideki Irabu,Jaret Wright,Jose Contreras,Kyle Farnsworth, Kenny Rogers,Kevin Brown,RANDY JOHNSON and Carl Provano​

 

[Philip J. Fry]

a lot of players who came to the darkside couldnt cut it.


View attachment 363976


just the pitchers

Kei Igawa,Hideki Irabu,Jaret Wright,Jose Contreras,Kyle Farnsworth, Kenny Rogers,Kevin Brown,RANDY JOHNSON and Carl Provano​

To be fair to Jaret Wright, he sucked before he was a Yankee. Alcoholism will wreck a career.

 

[Philip J. Fry]

Wonder how he would be remembered if he went to Boston instead of the Yankees like was originally attempted?

Some people just aren’t cut out for New York. Randy Johnson had a rough time too.

Heh, if Arod went to Boston, maybe their curse wouldn't have been lifted in 2004.

 

[WizardofOz1982]

I'd take anyone over A-Rod. Pre-Yankees, I might say otherwise, but he was just a mess in the Bronx. Remember The Slap™?

View attachment 363973

ARod 2004 -2016 (Yankees career):
6,520 PAs, 1509 games, 51.5 fWAR, 138 wRC+, 351 HRs, 1012 Runs, 1096 RBIs, 152 SBs, .283/.378/.523, two 9 WAR seasons (Jeter never had one higher than 7 in his career)

Jeter 2004-2014:
7,079 PAs, 1535 games, 36.4 fWAR, 114 wRC+, 133 HRs, 997 Runs, 696 RBIs, 180 SBs, .303/.368/.423

Who was a mess in the Bronx? Rodriguez was always a worlds better player than Jeter and it isn't close.

 

[joey12508]

ARod 2004 -2016 (Yankees career):
6,520 PAs, 1509 games, 51.5 fWAR, 138 wRC+, 351 HRs, 1012 Runs, 1096 RBIs, 152 SBs, .283/.378/.523, two 9 WAR seasons (Jeter never had one higher than 7 in his career)

Jeter 2004-2014:
7,079 PAs, 1535 games, 36.4 fWAR, 114 wRC+, 133 HRs, 997 Runs, 696 RBIs, 180 SBs, .303/.368/.423

Who was a mess in the Bronx? Rodriguez was always a worlds better player than Jeter and it isn't close.

Jeter the better man, AROD not close, he had immense talent was a falled human.