Manning now equals Favre

[mwashuc06]

1 SB win 1 SB loss

Both will be the TD and Yards record holders.

Both will never see another superbowl.

 

[ffgameman]

1 SB win 1 SB loss

Both will be the TD and Yards record holders.

Both will never see another superbowl.

Manning still has quite a few years left in him with a good team.

 

[cowboysrule48]

Troy Aikman never lost a Super Bowl...

 

[gt2590]

WAAAAAAY too early to say Manning won't get back. He'll probably have more than one left in his career.

And personally, to me, it looked like more Wayne's fault on that pick than Manning's. Favre's picks usually are just him throwing dangerous passes.

 

[ffgameman]

WAAAAAAY too early to say Manning won't get back. He'll probably have more than one left in his career.

And personally, to me, it looked like more Wayne's fault on that pick than Manning's. Favre's picks usually are just him throwing dangerous passes.

Plus Wayne should have caught the touchdown pass in the last minute of the game. Wouldn't have done much, but it was right there in his hands.

 

[colts1888]

the colts next year on paper are a better team then they are now manning will win atleast 1 more and win 1-2 more MVPs so hes now way equal to favre

 

[Card Magnet]

WAAAAAAY too early to say Manning won't get back. He'll probably have more than one left in his career.

And personally, to me, it looked like more Wayne's fault on that pick than Manning's. Favre's picks usually are just him throwing dangerous passes.

:mrgreen:

 

[19braves77]

Peyton lost his sense of mind with that INT and he could have made a better effort to slow down Tracy Porter. Just dive into his legs.

 

[kdailey4315]

Troy Aikman never lost a Super Bowl...

Montana never even threw an interception in a Super Bowl. Oh, and he never lost one either.

 

[cowboysrule48]

Troy Aikman never lost a Super Bowl...

Montana never even threw an interception in a Super Bowl. Oh, and he never lost one either.

I know. I'm just living in my dream world where Aikman is the best ever haha.

 

[kdailey4315]

Troy Aikman never lost a Super Bowl...

Montana never even threw an interception in a Super Bowl. Oh, and he never lost one either.

I know. I'm just living in my dream world where Aikman is the best ever haha.

More power to you. LOL. I love pointing out stuff like that about Montana also.

 

[stu]

Manning and Favre never said no to a commercial offer.

 

[KandKCards]

I think Manning is overrated to hell, but no way is he as unreliable in big spots as Favre.

 

[Viking4Alpha]

I think Manning is overrated to hell.

LOL ok Patriot fan.

Peyton's 4 NFL MVP's would disagree with you.

 

[mwashuc06]

I think Manning is overrated to hell.

LOL ok Patriot fan.

Peyton's 4 NFL MVP's would disagree with you.

Well you can say A-Rod is the same as Manning, one time champ based on the players around them.

Manning won his superbowl based on Addai and Rex Grossman.

 

[cowboysrule48]

If Manning's career stays on course, in my mind he will be the best ever when he retires. Regardless if he gets back to this game or not.... Besides Aikman of course!

 

[mstng99tim]

I think Manning is overrated to hell.

LOL ok Patriot fan.

Peyton's 4 NFL MVP's would disagree with you.

Well you can say A-Rod is the same as Manning, one time champ based on the players around them.

Manning won his superbowl based on Addai and Rex Grossman.

Manning never got caught taking steroids though.

 

[mwashuc06]

If Manning's career stays on course, in my mind he will be the best ever when he retires. Regardless if he gets back to this game or not.... Besides Aikman of course!

Manning will not be the best of all time. Montana is above him due to being 4-0 in the Superbowl and Brady will be above him, Brady I think gets 1 or 2 more rings. Like I said before Manning is Favre or a Richmans Marino. Manning got his ring based on a great performance by Addai in the superbowl and Rex Grossman playing terrible. I think the Bears win that game with Kyle Orton in the game.

 

[allstars]

I think Manning is overrated to hell, but no way is he as unreliable in big spots as Favre.

I thought Peyton played great. He was kept off the field in the pivotal 2nd 1/4.

 

[Viking4Alpha]

If Manning's career stays on course, in my mind he will be the best ever when he retires. Regardless if he gets back to this game or not.... Besides Aikman of course!

Manning will not be the best of all time. Montana is above him due to being 4-0 in the Superbowl and Brady will be above him, Brady I think gets 1 or 2 more rings. Like I said before Manning is Favre or a Richmans Marino. Manning got his ring based on a great performance by Addai in the superbowl and Rex Grossman playing terrible. I think the Bears win that game with Kyle Orton in the game.

Curious, then why didn't Addai get SB MVP?