- Thread starter
- #1
Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.
ya i originally thought that, but looking at the numbers, i could see him barely cracking the top 9, but yes still questionable.NYCrulesU said:I agree with all but Papelbon.
1.84 career ERAdarocker80 said:ya i originally thought that, but looking at the numbers, i could see him barely cracking the top 9, but yes still questionable.NYCrulesU said:I agree with all but Papelbon.
I agree, but I think the WS rings helped a bit...championMan said:Is not that Papelbon isn't a great closer. Is the idea of the decade. I think U really have to play 5 full season to be consider fairly.
longevityscotty21690 said:1.84 career ERAdarocker80 said:ya i originally thought that, but looking at the numbers, i could see him barely cracking the top 9, but yes still questionable.NYCrulesU said:I agree with all but Papelbon.
38 saves/year average
10.4 K/9
.98 WHIP
and 2 WS rings
Who would you put over him?
(Not saying he should be #1, but should be on the list...moreso towards the end though)
championMan said:Is not that Papelbon isn't a great closer. Is the idea of the decade. I think U really have to play 5 full season to be consider fairly.
AndyLaroche#1Fan said:Gagne higher up personally. Most saves without blowing one? Pretty good..
AndruwHRJones said:championMan said:Is not that Papelbon isn't a great closer. Is the idea of the decade. I think U really have to play 5 full season to be consider fairly.
So what other closer in the decade played 5 full seasons and has better stats or equal stats to Papelbon? You come up with an answer and I will agree with the people who think Papelbon should not be on the list.
markakis8 said:Agreed. In their prime, after Mo and Billy Wagner, I'd take Gagne over any of the others.
AndyLaroche#1Fan said:Gagne higher up personally. Most saves without blowing one? Pretty good..
bodiaz said:That is an ignorant comment. Yeah because one of the effects of steriods is it makes you pitch unhittable balls? Steriods is such a small advantage, and fans make such a HUGE deal about it! Really gets old.
bodiaz said:That is an ignorant comment. Yeah because one of the effects of steriods is it makes you pitch unhittable balls? Steriods is such a small advantage, and fans make such a HUGE deal about it! Really gets old.