OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Thanks for the Input

[MattinglyAlexander]

Feedback appreciated.

 

[JVC]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

Those look awesome.

 

[Phishmon23]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

I REALLY like the GU and the Autograph cards, however on the base and prospect cards I don't really like the wood tone towards the bottom of the card. I know other people would probably really like that...that trend has been popular in the past! Definitely a matter of opinion. In general however, I'm super impressed!

-Jason

 

[wideright]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

Shocked that you've gotten some Fail votes! :lol: Those are a nice set, i like how the game-used and autos have the football shaped areas.

 

[MattinglyAlexander]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

eh, you can't please everyone. You know, the "football shape never ever dawned on me. Guess it's destined to be a football set.

If someone doesn't like them, I wish they'd at least explain.

Shocked that you've gotten some Fail votes! :lol: Those are a nice set, i like how the game-used and autos have the football shaped areas.

 

[theplasticman]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

cool stuff! PM sent

 

[Guest]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

I think they look good. So it is your idea right? not something one of the car companies
are going to put out soon correct? I vote good

 

[marterburn]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

I don't really like the "graph paper" effect on the the autos and GU'd, and if the GU'd were to be produced I think you'd have a lot of creasing issues (with the die cut creasing out to the side). Other than that though, they're beautiful.

 

[beefycheddar]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

FAIL!!!

Just kidding, felt like saying that and feeling younger...... They look great.

 

[matfanofold]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

I voted Fail.


Simply put, I just do not like the look at all. Sure, it's better than I could do and a give a + for ambition. But as a cars set, I would not look twice at them as they are just not appealing to me. And I collect whats appealing to me, not the herd. Hopefully you will respect my opinion and take it for what it's worth..

Good luck though!

 

[MattinglyAlexander]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

Well, do you really think I'd have posted this if I couldn't handle it?
Believe me, it's not like I expect everyone to love them. It's ok....

~loads bolt action winchester 30/30~

I voted Fail.


Simply put, I just do not like the look at all. Sure, it's better than I could do and a give a + for ambition. But as a cars set, I would not look twice at them as they are just not appealing to me. And I collect whats appealing to me, not the herd. Hopefully you will respect my opinion and take it for what it's worth..

Good luck though!

 

[matfanofold]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

Well, do you really think I'd have posted this if I couldn't handle it?
Believe me, it's not like I expect everyone to love them. It's ok....

~loads bolt action winchster 30/30~

I voted Fail.


Simply put, I just do not like the look at all. Sure, it's better than I could do and a give a + for ambition. But as a cars set, I would not look twice at them as they are just not appealing to me. And I collect whats appealing to me, not the herd. Hopefully you will respect my opinion and take it for what it's worth..

Good luck though!

I'd just like to add they do have a polished, professional look, so if that was your goal, you indeed passed! It's just I took the poll as personal prefrence. I wish I had the talent to design whats in my head!

 

[Jurgy25]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

Cool design, just kind of reminds me of like a Nabisco card, or cards inserted in a bag of chips. Auto and GU are pretty cool though.

 

[chuckbartowski]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

For the most part, they are great, but I tend to agree with the poster about the wood look at the bottom.

 

[MattinglyAlexander]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

I think they look good. So it is your idea right? not something one of the car companies
are going to put out soon correct? I vote good

 

[Topnotchsy]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

I like the design. For me it looks like it would be a great design for a lower end set that would appeal to kids. Just my opinion.

 

[theplasticman]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

I think they look good. So it is your idea right? not something one of the car companies
are going to put out soon correct? I vote good

Sorry, I know you meant something else but this made me :lol:

 

[scotty21690]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

I like them!!

 

[MattinglyAlexander]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

I guess it's a fail then.

 

[MattinglyAlexander]

Re: OPINION POLL: Fail or Fantastic? Original Design

I tried everything else...nothing else looked right.

For the most part, they are great, but I tend to agree with the poster about the wood look at the bottom.