Opinions Needed...Real or Fake signed All Star jersey? PICS!

[Messier2]

I say 100% real on all of them. All you haters are just jealous...that's all...simple as that! :evil:

 

[bigpops65]

The last mystery player is Jonathan Papelbon.

To me, the Papelbon looks legit, the Pedroia is his style, probably rushed. The Lester seems a little off, his signature is usually crisper and cleaner, but it could be the surface/material.

Nice buy!

 

[Krom]

FAKE? i Don't think so. Too many are Perfect. Most good fakes don't look anywhere as good as these.

 

[cubsfan_2007]

Thanks for the replys.


One member mentioned the swisher auto, and yes you're right, ive never seen a swisher auto like that either, i just guessed that it was swisher, its quite an odd sig.

The only thing i can say about Mauer putting his number is that he might have signed better because of the piece that was being signed. If you're signing a team signed jersey than maybe they put a little more effort into it, idk.

As for the Philip Hughes, i'm not too worried about that sig being fake, of all the sigs on the jersey im sure that's not the one to worry about. It looks close enough to me.

Ill be bringing this to the Chicago Sun Times show, so if anyone is setting up, lmk i can run by and show you if it passed PSA/DNA. I only won it for $150.00 so if it doesn't pass i wont fret, i think its a sweet item, and i'm sure i can sell it to someone for $150.00 even if i told them it didn't pass, just because it looks this real..

 

[cubsfan_2007]

Some people are commenting (not just here) that this ichiro auto is way off. I dont see how it is i mean look, his auto looks like a 3 year olds sig and NONE are the same

Compared to PSA

 

[erniesims50]

Good luck getting it authenticated, I don't see it passing.

- The Jeter sig alone wouldn't pass.

- I haven't seen Rivera sign with that R in a VERY long time.

- I saw the NL AS jersey the guy was selling and the Pujols was horrible.

The Jeter looks like every Jeter auto ive ever seen.....

 

[cubsfan_2007]

Yea Jeters has been forged a lot lately, but this looks legit.

Compared to this PSA signed hat

 

[erniesims50]

Yea Jeters has been forged a lot lately, but this looks legit.

Compared to this PSA signed hat

The Jeter looks great man, Id say you got a steal on the jersey! some people think they are the expert opinion on autographs when really they dont know crap

 

[A_Pharis]

I don't see the point of defending the graphs, tho. Just send it to PSA and be done with it.

 

[Big Mac McGwire]

Mystery sig 1 is Carmona, #2 looks like Lee or a rushed Utley (don't know if he was even there)

The Crawford, Longoria, Hughes, Cahill, and Rivera signatures don't look quite right. Could be because of how the jersey was signed, being that it's not a very sturdy object to sign so there can be some variation. Especially, the Hughes, Crawford, and Longoria signatures though aren't very consistent with ones I've seen from them.

That being said, some of the others do look good IMO, like the Jeter and Vlad. I'm not an expert on Jeter signatures though. It's tough to say as a whole.

the longoria is bogus.

 

[theplasticman]

wow!

 

[drays4life]

Longoria has two autos. This one looks like the one that costs about $100 from his company. The ones he signs at games for free are considerably different. Just my 2 cents.

 

[Gonzaleznut]

Absolutely fantastic piece. And for the pricee, well worth the risk. The Hamilton, Kinsler and Andrus all look legit to me. Send it in to PSA/DNA and be done.

Awesome piece though. I would love to have it!!

 

[Lars]

We'll never hear from this guy again if any / or all autographs from that jersey fails PSA/DNA.

He didn't want opinions on authenticity, he wanted a pat in the back since he got a steal for $150.

Good luck buddy.

 

[A_Pharis]

Can anyone manage a link to the auction?

 

[011873]

1. Fausto
2. C Lee
4. Papelbon

 

[cubsfan_2007]

Can anyone manage a link to the auction?

Hope this works

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi ... _737wt_911

 

[Gwynn545]

That Ty Wiggington looks fake, so...



J/K! (Who's Ty Wiggington?)

I think it's an amazing piece! What a steal! Congrats!

 

[A_Pharis]

After viewing the auction (private bidding on just this auction, printing 8x10s from his own printer to sell), I probably wouldn't trust him. GOod luck with it!

 

[cubsfan_2007]

After viewing the auction (private bidding on just this auction, printing 8x10s from his own printer to sell), I probably wouldn't trust him. GOod luck with it!

You're right you wouldn't think o either, it doesnt add up. Strangely, this was posted on collector's universe and a random member asked if the seller was named tony because they set up at Frank and sons in California, sure enough thats who the seller is. They said if its Tony than its a legit piece. Maybe its a coincidence, but idk.