Percy Harvin wins Offensive ROY honors

[deceptikon1978]

That is disturbing :lol:

 

[schmidtfan20]

Minny stole another one, when many teams passed. My bucs have now skipped over two former ROY's. Did anyone
legit in the league really think that Wallace had a better season than Harvin? One vote, cmon man.

 

[Ryo1549]

I think you could've made the case for Austin Collie. He has as many receptions as harvin and 1 more receiving touchdown. However the return stuff is what put harvin over the edge.

 

[ctmike]

I think you could've made the case for Austin Collie. He has as many receptions as harvin and 1 more receiving touchdown. However the return stuff is what put harvin over the edge.

That and the Favre effect, don't think that didn't help. He doesn't get a sniff with Tarvaris or Sage. Totally different vote would have happened.

 

[Randy Shields]

http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d8158aa40&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true

Really a no brainer imo.

What do you think?

I think it's a good choice. I'm partial though. I think this kid could be a good one for a long time if they can get his migraine troubles figured out. They said he's had them since he was a kid, but they don't know what causes them. He missed 1 game due to them.
This award could have went to Collie just as easily to be honest though.

 

[Ryo1549]

I think you could've made the case for Austin Collie. He has as many receptions as harvin and 1 more receiving touchdown. However the return stuff is what put harvin over the edge.

That and the Favre effect, don't think that didn't help. He doesn't get a sniff with Tarvaris or Sage. Totally different vote would have happened.

Do you think that he wouldn't have gotten the return yards as well? Could also make the argument he would have gotten more touches with those QBs.

 

[ctmike]

I think you could've made the case for Austin Collie. He has as many receptions as harvin and 1 more receiving touchdown. However the return stuff is what put harvin over the edge.

That and the Favre effect, don't think that didn't help. He doesn't get a sniff with Tarvaris or Sage. Totally different vote would have happened.

Do you think that he wouldn't have gotten the return yards as well? Could also make the argument he would have gotten more touches with those QBs.

I think you can make any argument, but having watched Tarvaris I can say with a reasonable amount of certainty that Harvin would not have had the year he had with Favre. I don't know Rosenfels as well, but I am of the belief that Favre just made every receiver on the team better.