Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing
to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and
make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.
I always say buy the card and not the grade. If you like the price then buy them. Sorry I know this does not help but I
don;t know how much you should pay for the Kershaw anyway.
A base auto graded 9.5 10 averages about $80. I would say anywhere from $100-125. The $125 you were offered for it would be the absolute most I would go. Try and haggle and see if you can't bring the price down a bit to somewhere in the $110-115 range. Just my 2 pennies