Redemption replacement: Good or Bad?

[CubsfanP]

Don't know what to think of this one so I just wanted to ask you guys for opinions:

I pulled a 2011 Topps precision Demarco Murray Jumbo jersey auto redemption (not sure in the numbering) and of course he never signed. I asked for a replacement and here is what I received:

Good or Bad replacement?

 

[matfanofold]

Personally, I would have simply wanted what I should have gotten in the first place.

 

[notjomommasclint]

For collecting.. Leshoure
For flipping.. Murray

Personal opinion leshoure will be a 1200 yard 15 td guy year in year out. I like his long term better than Murray.

 

[f2tornado]

Cowboys fans tend to have deep pockets but Murray has been hurt while LeShoure is just getting going. Also, Platinum also has a bit more following than Precision. I remember some of the Purple /25 autos fetching good money last year. Not sure how well they've been holding up but gotta be better than anything in Precision.

 

[wheeler281]

Cowboys fans tend to have deep pockets but Murray has been hurt while LeShoure is just getting going. Also, Platinum also has a bit more following than Precision. I remember some of the Purple /25 autos fetching good money last year. Not sure how well they've been holding up but gotta be better than anything in Precision.

agreed. I think he did well

 

[Crewfan82]

For collecting.. Leshoure
For flipping.. Murray

Personal opinion leshoure will be a 1200 yard 15 td guy year in year out. I like his long term better than Murray.

This

 

[jbrown]

is it f/s?

 

[CubsfanP]

is it f/s?

Everything always is for the right price

 

[homerun28aa]

Rather have the Leshoure honestly