To be honest, using PEDS in football would be more like trying to tread water. Some of these guys are so strong it's insane. In baseball, I think it helps so much that if you can even hit the ball, you'll have the ability to turn into a monster. Of course it varies by each player and their god given talent. Plus it depends on what they take. But look at some of the guys who were already decent or damn good. Like Bonds. You take Bonds without steroids and he would have probably neared 600 homers and been a sure fire HOF. You give him roids and he turns into the all time home run champ and career leader? You have records standing forever in a day that got broken and surpassed by three different people within what...a few years span? Is that not saying something? Brady Anderson? Is that not saying something? In baseball it seems, you give a guy roids, the right kind, and leave him alone for long enough, he will do things the sport hasn't seen or at least make the damn near impossible look quite ordinary. Throughout the late 80's and 90's and even now, we have way too many guys hitting homers and just generally being as strong as hell. So I'd really like everyone to understand that roids are doing things that are well above the threshold of what I would call a minimum difference. Given to the right person with the right talent, the sky is the limit. I'd say that's a big deal. Given to a guy like let's say Hunter Pence or the like, you can turn a 20-25 hr a year guy into a 40 or 50 hr a year guy. You could probably turn a 10 hr guy into someone who can hit 25-30 a year. It's doing something.
With football, I've seen these players up close and also during training. If I had to play in the NFL, taking roids wouldn't be a thing I'd do to make a name for myself by being able to perform super feats. It would be more like trying to hold my own against some freak of nature who can naturally bench press 500 pounds and is capable of picking me up like a baby and snapping my spinal cord at every vertebrae in my body as easily as a candy cane.
Do I think either sport should allow it? Nope. But I'm not convinced roids can create as much of an un-level playing field in football as it can in baseball. At least not one we as fans will notice.
I pretty much agree that's why I feel the fans & people are generally more upset with baseball PED use because they know it is affecting the games outcomes & #'s more than PED use in football.