Topps Redemption Replacement Help

[yrocks2001]

I am asking Topps for two replacements on cards and would like to know what the Beckett value is that they are going to replace my cards with before I submit my email. If anyone can help me price these two cards with beckett value I'd really appreciate it (I want to know how many Angel Pagan cards they're sending me).

2011 Heritage Minor League Baseball Real One Autograph of Nolan Arenado
2011 Topps Finest Autographed Rookie Red Refractor of Mike Moustakas (not the jersey/auto)

Thanks!

 

[mudflap02]

Arenado will be a sticker. It's really short printed too. I might hold out for that one.

 

[Exposfan]

I would hold both. That's just me.

 

[ballerskrip]

Agreed, I would hold on both honestly

 

[TopOffLikeWALLACE]

Pretty sure the Arenado books for $50 because I bought it from a guy who sells at %50 bv for $25. Then I flipped it for $70! You'll probably get a crap replacement for this because of the unadjusted BV.

 

[yrocks2001]

I was told recently on another site the Arenado books for $120

 

[iconms]

I was told recently on another site the Arenado books for $120

That's correct. Replacement might be worth thinking about.

edit: Moustakas has N/A bv by the way

 

[yrocks2001]

Well, I rolled the dice and requested replacements for both cards since I wasn't very attached to them and only had about $40 total into them.

Here is what I received today...

I was very pleased with the Martinez and the Cabrera is also a SP limited to 49 copies so I can't complain there either.

 

[mudflap02]

Wow I would say you did VERY well.

I have about 15 Lineage redemptions outstanding. I am probably going to roll the dice on those.

 

[George_Calfas]

Congrats, but I will ask the obvious......how did you get a Red Refractor auto?

 

[yrocks2001]

Congrats, but I will ask the obvious......how did you get a Red Refractor auto?

Yeah, I was thinking the same thing. I initially thought someone may have sent it in for replacement because of a scratch but I've looked it over very closely and it appears to be in amazing condition.