Holy Crap! Awesome cards, guys! Wow, I don't know who to vote for, yet!!
Okay, I'll Edit with some justification, like if my opinion really matters:
Autocut: Solid, I like the "painted" look...
Bigunit: the FCB ruined it for me (no offense to anyone)
Fordman: Beautiful. Looks like it should be a card already! Especially the patch version.
HOF Vintage: Beautiful. They both look familiar, which is not necessarily a bad thing. I like #1 better, but the Ultimate Collection is already used.
JBHoffman: Nice! I am not a fan of Perfection Collection title (obviously the OP feels otherwise) Out of the other two, the Silhouette is awesome!
Matfanofold: Nice, except for the Shame Game. The wood is a great idea, but tough to pull off. My favorite of your three.
National Treasure: Very solid. Again, they look familiar. Not a fan of Triple Threads, so the Date one is out. First one is my favorite of the two.
TyHope: Love the effort, as a 90's guy I am loving the "Museum Collection" look. Needs a border, though. Feel like it's cropped to close.
Top three: Autocut, Fordman Patch, JBHofman Silhouette
Does Autocut's have a Barrell on it? That would make it a JUMBO! And JB's Silhouette, I wish it had his first name.