- Thread starter
- #1
Welcome to our community
Be apart of something great, join today!
whos an expert on mcgwire signatures?
- Thread starter J.O.
- Start date
Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.
use psa's quick opinion
- Thread starter
- #3
J.O. said:
if it's PSA/DNA'd then no one on this board is qualified enough to overturn it
your only concern should be to make sure you get a slab that hasn't been tampered with
- Thread starter
- #5
cgilmo said:
alright whatever i'm going to post the two here since its a BIN and no on will get mad
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi ... K:MEWAX:IT
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi ... K:MEWAX:IT
autocut
Active member
cgilmo said:
Not true.
Rubber stamp. PSa/DNA remove it from database after they were informed. Things does slip through.
mchenrycards
Featured Contributor, Vintage Corner, Senior Membe
Razor said:
Someone has to ask......
was this auto you have for sale destined for razor packs at one point or is this from your personal collection?
mchenrycards said:
why does it matter?
mchenrycards said:
We have no post 1970 autograph card projects on schedule at moment....
We will be using PRE-1970 HALL OF FAMERS SIGNED CARDS IN A 2010 Spring release!!!!! 1985 Topps MAC auto is neither HOF or pre-70....
At one point we considered putting cards like this into a vintage product, but it would ruin the "vintage" feel,.... BG
BG
mchenrycards
Featured Contributor, Vintage Corner, Senior Membe
cgilmo said:
Because I was curious!!
Chris, I believe Brian is a big boy and can take care of himself. Brian, Thank you for your answer!
Big Mac McGwire
New member
cgilmo said:
on the contrary. I have seen ALOT of PSA/DNA'd mcgwire cards that were so fake it was not even funny. They know as much as the hardcore mcgwire like myself do. Id give myself and the other mcgwire collectors for the nod simply because that's basically ALL we collect.
scotty21690
New member
- Aug 7, 2008
- 16,150
- 0
You got my interest, Brian!!!Razor said:mchenrycards said:
We have no post 1970 autograph card projects on schedule at moment....
We will be using PRE-1970 HALL OF FAMERS SIGNED CARDS IN A 2010 Spring release!!!!! 1985 Topps MAC auto is neither HOF or pre-70....
At one point we considered putting cards like this into a vintage product, but it would ruin the "vintage" feel,.... BG
BG
I have quite a few pre70 vintage card autos, sadly none are FS though. As long as these autos are not being chopped up then I am all for it!!
G $MONEY$ said:
either you underrate psa
or you overrate fcb
itsinthegrade
New member
cgilmo said:
I use both Psa & Jsa & I will tell you that they are only giving a opinion (like most of us know). But in my opinion Psa doesnt seem to know the sigs of Pujols & Jeter.
- Aug 7, 2008
- 3,490
- 12
cgilmo said:
In my opinion, I know two Mcgwire collectors that are more qualified to slab McGwire auto's than PSA. I would take their opinion over PSA any day regarding cards I would add to my collection.
In some situations, there are better experts out there. Working for PSA doesn't magically make your opinion better than it was the day before you started working for PSA.
autocut
Active member
onionring9 said:
PSA/DNA screws up a lot, but they are human like anyone else. They've certified rubber stamps, facsimiles, and altered (second market hand numbered) cards. When dealing with autographs, no matter if it is in a PSA/DNA or JSA/BGS holder, you still have to do your own homework.
Big Mac McGwire
New member
Im not trying to toot my own horn, but i have been collecting mcgwire signatures for almost 20 years. 19 years to be exact. I have a total of 207 autographs (195 Different items) yet it is my own opinion that all of them besides the ones i got from steiner and the 12 i have gotten in person are real. But how can you tell me some guy at PSA/DNA knows more about mcgwire signatures then me?? He is soley what i collect. What makes a person an expert??? If i am not one, i would like someone to point me to someone who has been collecting his signatures longer then i have and has more then i do. 1 person comes to mind and that is Randall Hahn of mcgwire.com. I talk to Randall from time to time and i have more Mac signatures then he does. I gurantee all of my signatures would pass authentication. And i STILL have my doubts about 1 of them. I along with other mcgwire collectors such as Onionring and McGwire Museum have seen ALOT of Bogus cards authenticated by PSA/DNA. But like Onionring said, besides hardcore mcgwire collectors who could be possibly me more knowledgable with his autograph then his hardcore collectors???
