- Thread starter
- #1
Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.
andyduke86 said:500 HR doesn't mean nearly what it used to. 600 is the new 500.
I don't think anyone can say that Thome has been one of the 2 or 3 best first basemen in baseball during his career.
hofautos said:Out of 20 votes so far, I am the only one to say Holliday is in!
I love it...5 more years and we will see how the vote swings... :lol: :mrgreen:
markakis8 said:I voted no b/c he's playing in his 6th MLB season....really hard to gauge HOF only 5 1/2 seasons.
That's like asking if you think David Wright or Hanley Ramirez should be in the HOF....
hofautos said:Out of 20 votes so far, I am the only one to say Holliday is in!
I love it...5 more years and we will see how the vote swings... :lol: :mrgreen:
Frow said:markakis8 said:I voted no b/c he's playing in his 6th MLB season....really hard to gauge HOF only 5 1/2 seasons.
That's like asking if you think David Wright or Hanley Ramirez should be in the HOF....
hofautos said:Out of 20 votes so far, I am the only one to say Holliday is in!
I love it...5 more years and we will see how the vote swings... :lol: :mrgreen:
Agree...when the player is barely half way to being eligable for consideration that's kind of stretching the conversation.
hofautos said:Frow said:markakis8 said:I voted no b/c he's playing in his 6th MLB season....really hard to gauge HOF only 5 1/2 seasons.
That's like asking if you think David Wright or Hanley Ramirez should be in the HOF....
hofautos said:Out of 20 votes so far, I am the only one to say Holliday is in!
I love it...5 more years and we will see how the vote swings... :lol: :mrgreen:
Agree...when the player is barely half way to being eligable for consideration that's kind of stretching the conversation.
Now's the time to "speculate". In 5 more years, it will be obvious... :mrgreen:
pujolsthomefan33 said:hofautos said:Frow said:markakis8 said:I voted no b/c he's playing in his 6th MLB season....really hard to gauge HOF only 5 1/2 seasons.
That's like asking if you think David Wright or Hanley Ramirez should be in the HOF....
hofautos said:Out of 20 votes so far, I am the only one to say Holliday is in!
I love it...5 more years and we will see how the vote swings... :lol: :mrgreen:
Agree...when the player is barely half way to being eligable for consideration that's kind of stretching the conversation.
Now's the time to "speculate". In 5 more years, it will be obvious... :mrgreen:
I presume we are still talking about Holliday here.......Mike, I think at this point it depends on where Holliday ends up after the season is over......he stays with the Cardinals or goes to another team where he fits well, he will continue to post some HUGE numbers......if he ends up somewhere like Oakland again, forget it.
TK