Peyton Manning or Tom Brady?

[kdailey4315]

Didnt Brady win 2 of his superbowls with the leg of his kicker? js

1 for sure against the Rams. Not sure of the other one. Adam V. is definitely the most clutch post season kicker ever.

 

[tide12champrings]

Peyton Manning

 

[bmoore997]

Sure is quiet in Indy right now

 

[KOBEARODLT]

Sure is quiet in Indy right now

yeah it was kind of expected considering indy is missing basically everyone of their starting secondary players

 

[kdailey4315]

Sure is quiet in Indy right now

yeah it was kind of expected considering indy is missing basically everyone of their starting secondary players

Much like the last decade, whoever has lost the regular season game has won the playoff game. I guess this is good for the Colts so far.

 

[lumm0x]

Peyton Manning would be my preference but it's close. I like all the intangibles of Manning over Brady. Athletically they are neck and neck.

I cannot believe anyone would say it isn't close going either way. I guess the gross seperation would be just jaded homerism.

 

[Viking4Alpha]

Sure is quiet in Indy right now

You were saying?? lololololololololololololololol!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[KOBEARODLT]

there is a reason belichek just went for it on fourth down with the lead on their own 30....manning is the best

 

[EricInCT]

Manning would have carved up the D regardless.

Manning when it is all said and done, will be better than Brady by a wide margin.

 

[JEA2880]

Sure is quiet in Indy right now

Jets Jersey - $60
Autograph Joe Namath Photo - $100
Being able to quote this guy's post and subject him to endless humiliation?

PRICELESS

 

[onionring9]

Manning.

Atheletically neither can run, they are precise and both have a cannon. Both spread the offense and neither need a huge running game to be successful.

Manning gets the heads up by his ability to read the defense when he gets to the line and audible to pick the D apart. That's why I'd take Manning over Brady.

 

[RITM]

Manning although I respect the fact that Brady has 3 rings.

What happened tonight shows the confidence people have in Manning. Amazing that a coach would go for it on 4th down from their own 28 in a 1 score game. I don't know that I've ever seen that type of respect for Brady in a game.

 

[JEA2880]

Manning although I respect the fact that Brady has 3 rings.

What happened tonight shows the confidence people have in Manning. Amazing that a coach would go for it on 4th down from their own 28 in a 1 score game. I don't know that I've ever seen that type of respect for Brady in a game.

To me, the fact that I had ZERO doubt in my mind that Manning was going to score a TD on each of the final two possessions shows his greatness. Unreal.

 

[kdailey4315]

Manning.

Atheletically neither can run, they are precise and both have a cannon. Both spread the offense and neither need a huge running game to be successful.

Manning gets the heads up by his ability to read the defense when he gets to the line and audible to pick the D apart. That's why I'd take Manning over Brady.

Brady's arm is average at best. He's accurate but far form having a cannon.

 

[flightposite]

Manning although I respect the fact that Brady has 3 rings.

What happened tonight shows the confidence people have in Manning. Amazing that a coach would go for it on 4th down from their own 28 in a 1 score game. I don't know that I've ever seen that type of respect for Brady in a game.

But having one of the best minds in football have the confidence in his QB to go for it in that spot... Well, I guess that just doesn't matter.

Bottom line, they are both great QBs. One has two Super Bowl wins, the other has one. Both have broken the TD record, one still owns it. Quite frankly, I'd be happy with either. I think Manning may have superior QB skills, but if I need to win a game, I'm going with Brady. Just like Montana to Marino, I'm always going to take the big game QB over big stat QB. Also, I don't think Brady gets too much credit for being a great QB.

I can see how anyone can argue either way though, as they are both in the all-time great category.

 

[Nate Colbert 17]

Both are very good QB's. Peyton has done more with less. Brady stepped into a Super Bowl caliber team, but Manning inherited nothing when he came to Indy. (The Patriots also have had better defenses throughout the years.)

I give the nod to Manning.

 

[cowboysrule48]

I've always thought that Brady was one of the most overrated QBs in the league, and his success has come from the team around him and the coaching. I'm not saying isn't a great QB, you have to be to win that much, I'm just saying he is far from being the best in the league or the best ever.

Just look at what Cassel did last year.

 

[Tomlinson21RB]

Manning.

Atheletically neither can run, they are precise and both have a cannon. Both spread the offense and neither need a huge running game to be successful.

Manning gets the heads up by his ability to read the defense when he gets to the line and audible to pick the D apart. That's why I'd take Manning over Brady.

Brady's arm is average at best. He's accurate but far form having a cannon.

Dumbest comment in this thread.

 

[madman1978]

Manning
After the game last night I dont believe there would be another choice.

 

[flightposite]

Both are very good QB's. Peyton has done more with less. Brady stepped into a Super Bowl caliber team, but Manning inherited nothing when he came to Indy. (The Patriots also have had better defenses throughout the years.)

I give the nod to Manning.

LOLZ.

Brady won a Super Bowl with Antowain Smith, Deion Branch, & Troy Brown.

Manning? Joseph Addai, Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Dallas Clark. The Colts back up RB (Rhodes) was better than Antowain.