- Thread starter
- #1
crowhop
New member
each person nominate a guy that you think is one of the greatest handful of players ever. these should be quite obvious and need no debate. after all the Top guys are gone, we'll go to Tier 2 and so on down the list. these guys should be ones that would make the 25 man roster of the All-Time MLB team.
if someone is nominated that you think is NOT a Top guy, debate it out.
i'll nominate:
Ted Williams
http://www.baseball-reference.com/w/willite01.shtml
UPDATE:
here's the list thus far:
1 P Walter Johnson
2 P Lefty Grove
3 P Cy Young
4 P Christy Mathewson
5 P Bob Feller
6 P Warren Spahn
7 P Sandy Koufax
8 P Pete Alexander
9 P Eddie Plank
10 1B Lou Gehrig
11 1B Jimmie Foxx
12 2B Rogers Hornsby
13 2B Jackie Robinson
14 3B Mike Schmidt
15 SS Honus Wagner
16 OF Stan Musial
17 OF Ted Williams
18 OF Henry Aaron
19 OF Ty Cobb
20 OF Willie Mays
21 OF Babe Ruth
22 OF Joe DiMaggio
23 OF Tris Speaker
24 OF Mickey Mantle
25 2B Nap Lajoie
if someone is nominated that you think is NOT a Top guy, debate it out.
i'll nominate:
Ted Williams
http://www.baseball-reference.com/w/willite01.shtml
UPDATE:
here's the list thus far:
1 P Walter Johnson
2 P Lefty Grove
3 P Cy Young
4 P Christy Mathewson
5 P Bob Feller
6 P Warren Spahn
7 P Sandy Koufax
8 P Pete Alexander
9 P Eddie Plank
10 1B Lou Gehrig
11 1B Jimmie Foxx
12 2B Rogers Hornsby
13 2B Jackie Robinson
14 3B Mike Schmidt
15 SS Honus Wagner
16 OF Stan Musial
17 OF Ted Williams
18 OF Henry Aaron
19 OF Ty Cobb
20 OF Willie Mays
21 OF Babe Ruth
22 OF Joe DiMaggio
23 OF Tris Speaker
24 OF Mickey Mantle
25 2B Nap Lajoie
