What is the smallest PT size for toploaders...

[ffgameman]

all i know is that the Generic ones WalMart carries now are the thinnest ever made -
and sometimes don't even fit my base cards/autos.

They wouldn't fit a standard 2011 Topps base card for me (without a sleeve).

I think these are the ones I'm looking for. But you are saying they don't fit a regular base topps card?

They did not for me. I even stretched the inside of the toploader, and still no luck. I could eventually get one in, but it wasn't safe for the card.

They were made by some offshoot company - not Ultra Pro.

Hmmm I'll stay away, thanks for the heads up

For the record they are made by a "Noteworthy". It's possible those carried by other Walmarts are different - but if you see any thin toploaders by this company I would avoid.