Your Favorite Franchise's Mt. Rushmore

[scotty21690]

Astros: Berkman, Biggio, Bagwell, Oswalt

No love for Mike Hampton?

 

[Todd44]

Washington Nationals:

Ryan Zimmerman
Livan Hernandez

I kind of feel like those two are easy. But then it gets a lot tougher.

Do I just go with the future? Strasburg and Harper?

Or go with players that made an impact during their brief time here: Alfonso Soriano, Chad Cordero or Dmitri Young?

 

[Halonut]

Angels: Rod Carew, Jim Fregosi, Nolan Ryan, Tim Salmon

+1

 

[bouwob]

Angels: Rod Carew, Jim Fregosi, Nolan Ryan,

Tim Salmon

vlad has to go in before tim

 

[scotty21690]

Washington Nationals:

Ryan Zimmerman
Livan Hernandez

I kind of feel like those two are easy. But then it gets a lot tougher.

Do I just go with the future? Strasburg and Harper?

Or go with players that made an impact during their brief time here: Alfonso Soriano, Chad Cordero or Dmitri Young?

Expos?


...or maybe just Harper x4.

 

[bouwob]

Just so people remember, there are 4 faces on Mt. Rushmore, not 5.

Cubs:

Cap Anson
Mordecai Brown
Ernie Banks
Ryne Sandberg

i would put harry carry on this one.

 

[tpeichel]

Washington Nationals:

Ryan Zimmerman
Livan Hernandez

I kind of feel like those two are easy. But then it gets a lot tougher.

Do I just go with the future? Strasburg and Harper?

Or go with players that made an impact during their brief time here: Alfonso Soriano, Chad Cordero or Dmitri Young?

Expos?


...or maybe just Harper x4.

Dawson, Raines, Gary Carter, Vlad

 

[bouwob]

I would also from the OP replace Juan Gonzalez with josh hamilton. Juan was an incredible player but his star tenure was during the steroid years. hamilton may have done crack, but he moved on and still proves he is a star.

Ryan was a first ballot and I believe that pudge will be as well. Young will not make it and juan will definitely never make it. That siad, I believe hamilton gets his spot.

 

[pujols5hof]

Washington Nationals:

Ryan Zimmerman
Livan Hernandez

I kind of feel like those two are easy. But then it gets a lot tougher.

Do I just go with the future? Strasburg and Harper?

Or go with players that made an impact during their brief time here: Alfonso Soriano, Chad Cordero or Dmitri Young?

Expos?


...or maybe just Harper x4.

Dawson, Raines, Gary Carter, Vlad

thanked

 

[383astro]

Braves

Aaron, Mathews, Murphy, Chipper

i couldn't agree more. and The Murph deserves to be in the HOF with his stats and defensive skills from his time. no one could touch him.

THIS!

I would have to build 2 Mt Rushmores

Aaron, Mathews, Murphy, Chipper

and

Maddux, Spahn, Niekro, Smoltz, Glavine

but Hey, there is an extra Statue of Liberty in Vegas, right?

 

[tpeichel]

Colorado Rockies:

1. Todd Helton
2. Larry Walker
3. Dante Bichette
4. Vinny Castilla
5. Andres Galarraga

I'd take Galaragga over Castilla, but Tulo is getting mighty close to displacing both of them.

 

[D-Lite]

Washington Nationals:

Ryan Zimmerman
Livan Hernandez

I kind of feel like those two are easy. But then it gets a lot tougher.

Do I just go with the future? Strasburg and Harper?

Or go with players that made an impact during their brief time here: Alfonso Soriano, Chad Cordero or Dmitri Young?

Expos?


...or maybe just Harper x4.

Dawson, Raines, Gary Carter, Vlad

What, no El Presidente?

 

[Gwynn545]

Padres:
Gwynn, Gwynn's wife Alicia, Gwynn's son Tony Jr., and Gwynn's brother Chris.




Although some will make a case for Trevor Hoffman
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
It's really sad, actually, Padres had some great players but none really specific to San Diego (besides the two above):
Alomar, McGriff, Winfield, Ozzie, Caminiti, Finley, Nettles, Templeton, Maddux, Rollie Fingers, Goose Gossage, even so far as Adrian Gonzalez... No one stuck around too long in San Diego.

 

[IndyManning18]

Who's the 5th President on Mt. Rushmore?

For my Cubs:

Cap Anson, Ernie Banks, Ron Santo, Ryne Sandberg

 

[RL24]

Just so people remember, there are 4 faces on Mt. Rushmore, not 5.

Well, I know you think the people who listed 5 players are total morons, but the original post says:

I know there are only four presidents on Mt. Rushmore, but I would expand it to as many as 5 players who most epitomize the history of a franchise.

Moron. :lol:

 

[Ryan The Orange]

Musial, Pujols, Gibson, Ozzie

 

[alabamalongsnake]

Braves

Aaron, Mathews, Murphy, Chipper

i couldn't agree more. and The Murph deserves to be in the HOF with his stats and defensive skills from his time. no one could touch him.

Aaron Mathews Spahn maddux

But chipper glavine niekro.smoltzie all deserve consideration and heck in five years may be McCann . Loved the Dale growing up but just doesn't get there

 

[vwnut13]

Just so people remember, there are 4 faces on Mt. Rushmore, not 5.

Well, I know you think the people who listed 5 players are total morons, but the original post says:

I know there are only four presidents on Mt. Rushmore, but I would expand it to as many as 5 players who most epitomize the history of a franchise.

Moron. :lol:

I guess you haven't been to Mt. Rushmore lately.

In the healthcare bill there was a $321m project to add Obama to Mt. Rushmore.

 

[RedsFan2993]

Reds:

Pete Rose
Johnny Bench
Joe Morgan
Frank Robinson

 

[Brewer Andy]

Braves

Aaron, Mathews, Murphy, Chipper

i couldn't agree more. and The Murph deserves to be in the HOF with his stats and defensive skills from his time. no one could touch him.

Aaron Mathews Spahn maddux

But chipper glavine niekro.smoltzie all deserve consideration and heck in five years may be McCann . Loved the Dale growing up but just doesn't get there

You know Milwaukee's Rushmore could be Aaron, Spahn, Mathews, Molitor, and Yount. They belong here more anyway. Then you can have your Maddux's and Murphys